Is raw milk healthier than pasteurised milk?
The claim
Unpasteurised milk retains vitamins, enzymes, bioactive proteins and beneficial bacteria that pasteurisation destroys or reduces, and drinking it in childhood protects against asthma and allergies.
The case for
“Moreover, raw milk supplies enzymes and carrier proteins to ensure that 100 percent of every nutrient is absorbed. Pasteurization destroys all these important co-factors.”
A Campaign for Real Milk, campaign website · 2021-02 · source
“Physicians have noted that the consumption of raw milk is a strong factor in reducing the risk of asthma.”
A Campaign for Real Milk, campaign website · 2021-05 · source
“Bioactives are destroyed in pasteurization”
Mark McAfee, CEO of Raw Farm and chairman of the Raw Milk Institute · 2025-01-17 · source
The case against
“While the perceived nutritional and health benefits of raw milk consumption have not been scientifically substantiated, the health risks are clear.”
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, federal regulator · 2024-03-05 · source
“a variety of environmental factors may be involved and there is no direct evidence that raw milk consumption is involved in any "protective" effect.”
John A. Lucey, professor of food science, University of Wisconsin-Madison · 2015-07 · source
“Though we haven’t had a confirmed human case of H5N1 from raw milk, we’ve had plenty of examples of animals getting infected by it”
Andrew Pekosz, professor of molecular microbiology and immunology, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health · 2025-01-17 · source
Quotes are short extracts, in the speakers' own words, about the claim or the evidence; each links to where it was said. Inclusion is not endorsement.
What the sources say
Evidence for this claim 4/10 · early human evidence
Pasteurisation lowers the levels of some vitamins in milk, including B1, B2, C and folate, but a 2011 systematic review judged the effect on its nutritional value minimal because milk contains these vitamins only at low levels. Large European studies of rural children, PARSIFAL (14,893 children) and GABRIELA (8,334), found that those who drank farm or raw milk had less asthma and hay fever; both are observational and cannot separate milk from other farm exposures, and in GABRIELA boiled farm milk showed no such association. No randomised trial has compared raw and pasteurised milk for any health outcome. A CDC and FDA analysis counted 75 US outbreaks with 675 illnesses linked to unpasteurised milk from 2013 to 2018, with 3.2 times as many outbreaks in states that expressly allowed sales as in states that prohibited retail sales. During the H5N1 outbreak in dairy cattle, the FDA found no viable virus in 464 pasteurised dairy products it tested and continues to advise against drinking raw milk.
Scores health benefits of raw over pasteurised milk (nutrition, asthma and allergy); the infection risk is well documented and is not what the score measures.
The record
- Regulator2024-03-05 · The FDA, which has prohibited the interstate sale of raw milk since 1987, states that the perceived nutritional and health benefits of raw milk consumption have not been scientifically substantiated. source
- Systematic review2011-11 · A 2011 systematic review and meta-analysis in the Journal of Food Protection found pasteurisation lowered vitamins B1, B2, C and folate but judged the effect on milk's nutritive value minimal because these vitamins occur at low levels in milk; a possible protective association with allergy (six studies) may be confounded by other farm factors. source
- Systematic review2022-10-25 · A CDC/FDA analysis (2022) counted 75 US outbreaks with 675 illnesses linked to unpasteurised milk in 2013-2018, 48% of illnesses in people aged 0-19, and 3.2 times as many outbreaks where sales were expressly allowed as where retail sales were prohibited. source
- Regulator2025-03-14 · During the 2024-2025 H5N1 outbreak in dairy cattle, the FDA reported that all 464 pasteurised dairy products it sampled were negative for viable virus and that it continues to advise against consuming raw milk. source
Sources: realmilk.com, realmilk.com, fortune.com, fda.gov, pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, fda.gov, pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.
Compiled by the Alivewire editors from the sources above, ; evidence last checked . This page describes the published evidence on a claim; it makes no judgement about the people who make it. We rely on sources we consider reputable but do not independently verify the facts they report. Not medical advice.
If you are quoted here and believe we have misstated your position, or if the evidence has moved, please tell us; an editor checks every report and corrects the page when it holds. How claims pages work.